Satisfying Warwick Valley’s craving
for authentic Italian food since 1987.

 
 

OUR STORY

Since 1987, Silvio and his son, Benito, have been happily preparing authentic Italian dishes for all of Warwick Valley. Using only the finest ingredients and recipes handed down from generations, Benito’s Pizzeria and Cafe has earned a reputation for serving up New York’s best slice of pizza as well as other delicious homemade specialties, like gnocchi primavera and salmon puttanesca.

In fact, Silvio and Benito have been offering up Italian dishes that are so delicious they’ve been making Italian grandmothers jealous for over 30 years.

We can cater any party or event, on or off premises. Call us for details.

We are CASH ONLY. No Credit Cards. An ATM is available. Thank you!

“Great pizza and sandwiches
Very friendly staff and owner.”

— Amy B.

“Didn't dine in ordered a personal cheese pizza and omg it was sooooo good!! Small thin slices which I thought it's going to be good but yes it was, so every time I'm in Warwick this is the pizza place to go.”

— Alicia Lyn S.

“Fantastic pizza! Service is always polite and outstanding. Never had a bad thing from this place.”

— Russell D.